Key Takeaway
When evaluating credit repair companies in Australia, the most important factors are: a valid ASIC Australian Credit Licence (verify at asic.gov.au), a genuine No Win No Fee structure, lawyer or legal professional oversight, independently verified reviews (not just testimonials on their own website), and a free initial assessment with honest feedback about your specific file. Australian Credit Solutions holds ACL 532003, operates No Win No Fee, is led by Principal Solicitor Elisa Rothschild, and has a 4.9/5 rating from 976+ independently verified reviews.
Quick Answer: When evaluating credit repair companies in Australia, the most important factors are: a valid ASIC Australian Credit Licence (verify at asic.gov.au), a genuine No Win No Fee structure, lawyer or legal professional oversight, independently verified reviews (not just testimonials on their own website), and a free initial assessment with honest feedback about your specific file. Australian Credit Solutions holds ACL 532003, operates No Win No Fee, is led by Principal Solicitor Elisa Rothschild, and has a 4.9/5 rating from 976+ independently verified reviews.
Choosing a credit repair company is a decision worth getting right. The industry attracts both genuine professionals who achieve real results and operators who collect upfront fees and deliver nothing. Knowing what separates them could save you thousands of dollars and months of frustration.
This guide explains exactly what to look for, what to avoid, and why the framework you use to evaluate any company matters more than any specific ranking.
The 6 Non-Negotiable Criteria for Any Credit Repair Company
1. Valid ASIC Australian Credit Licence
Credit repair is a regulated financial service in Australia. Any company providing credit assistance — including challenging items on a credit file — must hold an Australian Credit Licence (ACL) issued by ASIC. You can verify any licence in seconds at asic.gov.au.
Never engage a credit repair company that cannot provide their ACL number or whose licence you cannot verify. Operating without an ACL is illegal under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 — and if something goes wrong, you have no recourse.
ACS: ACL 532003 — verified at asic.gov.au.
2. No Win No Fee Structure
Legitimate credit repair companies operate on a No Win No Fee basis — you pay a success fee only when a default is actually removed from your credit file. This structure proves the company believes in its own ability to deliver results.
Companies demanding large upfront payments of $1,000–$5,000 before doing any work are the highest-risk operators in this space. If the challenge fails (or they never attempt it), you have little recourse. No Win No Fee aligns the company's financial interest with yours.
ACS: No Win No Fee. Success fees charged only on confirmed removal.
3. Legal Professional Oversight
Credit file disputes involve the Privacy Act 1988, Credit Reporting Code, and in escalated cases, formal legal proceedings through AFCA or the courts. Companies with a solicitor or legally qualified professional overseeing the process are better equipped to handle complex cases and escalate effectively when creditors resist.
ACS: Led by Principal Solicitor Elisa Rothschild, BA/LLB. Operates as a subsidiary of Fogarty Oliver and Rothschild law firm.
4. Independently Verified Reviews
Anyone can write testimonials on their own website. Independently verified reviews on Google, ProductReview, or Trustpilot — where real clients leave assessments that the company cannot edit or remove — are the credible signal. Look for: consistent four and five star ratings, specific detail about outcomes achieved, volume of reviews (not just a handful), and how the company responds to any negative feedback.
ACS: 4.9/5 from 976+ independently verified reviews. View ACS reviews →
5. Honest Free Assessment
A top-rated company tells you honestly what can and cannot be removed from your file before you commit to anything. If every company you speak to says "yes, we can fix that" regardless of what's on your file, that's a red flag. The reality is that some defaults were listed correctly and cannot be removed early. Honest assessment at the outset builds trust and saves wasted time.
ACS: Free credit assessment with written feedback within 24 hours. No pressure. No obligation.
6. Industry Recognition
Third-party recognition — industry awards, professional body membership, regulatory compliance track records — provides an external validation layer beyond the company's own claims. Three consecutive years of industry recognition (2022, 2023, 2024) from the same organisation indicates sustained performance, not a one-off result.
ACS: Industry Excellence Award winner — 2022, 2023, and 2024.
Red Flags to Avoid in Any Credit Repair Company
| Red Flag | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| No ASIC ACL number provided | Illegal to operate without it |
| Large upfront fees demanded before assessment | Legitimate companies assess first |
| "Guaranteed" results before seeing your file | Impossible to guarantee without file review |
| Promises to "create a new credit identity" | This is fraud — illegal under Australian law |
| No physical address or contact details | No accountability if something goes wrong |
| Reviews only on their own website | Not independently verifiable |
| No mention of the Privacy Act or Credit Reporting Code | Legal process — they should know the law |
Real Case Study: Darren, Rockhampton — Compared Three Companies Before Deciding
Darren, 38, a project manager from Brisbane, had two defaults on his Equifax file — one from a bank, one from a utility provider — pushing his score to 469. He contacted three companies before making a decision.
Company A: No ACL number when asked. Demanded $3,500 upfront. "Guaranteed" both defaults would be gone in 30 days. Darren declined.
Company B: Had an ACL. Charged $1,200 upfront before doing any assessment. Said they'd "look at his file once payment was received." Darren declined.
ACS: Free assessment first. Within 24 hours, Elisa's team confirmed the utility default had been listed during an active Energy Ombudsman complaint (Credit Reporting Code breach) and was removable. The bank default had been correctly listed with proper notice — and we told Darren clearly that we did not believe we could remove it. No misleading promises.
Darren engaged ACS for the utility default only. It was removed in 31 days. His score moved from 469 to 587. Not enough for mainstream lending on its own — but the bank default was now the only barrier, and his score trajectory was positive. He was approved for a car loan at a non-conforming rate and began rebuilding his CCR history.
Result: Darren's Equifax score moved from 469 to 587 in 31 days. One default correctly removed, one retained with honest explanation. He paid only when we succeeded. Subject to individual assessment; results may vary.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I check if a credit repair company is legitimate in Australia? Verify their Australian Credit Licence (ACL) at asic.gov.au. A licensed company will provide their ACL number voluntarily — if they hesitate or can't provide one, do not proceed. Also check independently verified reviews on Google or ProductReview, and confirm they operate on a No Win No Fee basis.
Are credit repair companies worth it in Australia? For defaults that were listed unlawfully, yes — professional removal is typically worth significantly more than the cost of the service when you consider the loan rate improvements it enables. For lawfully listed defaults with no grounds for removal, a legitimate company will tell you this upfront, saving you the cost of an attempt with no prospect of success.
What is the average success rate for credit repair companies in Australia? Legitimate, ASIC-licensed companies that carefully assess cases before accepting them typically report success rates of 85–98% on accepted cases. Australian Credit Solutions reports a 98% success rate on cases we accept. Note that acceptance itself involves an assessment — we don't accept every case, only those we believe meet legal grounds for removal.
How long does credit repair take in Australia? Most successful default removals are completed in 30–90 days from engagement. The timeline depends on how quickly the credit provider responds, whether escalation to AFCA is required, and the complexity of the evidence. Cases with clear documentation — like a missing Section 21D notice — often resolve in 2–4 weeks.
Can I do credit repair myself in Australia? Yes — the rights under the Privacy Act 1988 belong to you, and you can challenge your own credit file directly. The advantage of a professional service is experience with the legal grounds, documentation requirements, and escalation pathways. DIY success rates are lower for complex cases, but for straightforward inaccuracies (wrong personal information, expired entries still showing), DIY is absolutely viable.
What's the difference between credit repair and debt management? Credit repair challenges inaccurate or unlawfully listed information on your credit file — it's a legal process governed by the Privacy Act 1988. Debt management or debt consolidation deals with the underlying debts themselves. They're entirely separate services. ACS does credit repair only — we do not arrange debt repayment plans or negotiate debt settlements.
Start With an Honest Assessment
If you want to know whether your credit file has entries that can be legitimately removed — and which company is actually equipped to help — a free assessment from ACS is the no-risk starting point.
Australian Credit Solutions is ASIC-licensed (ACL 532003), lawyer-led, independently reviewed at 4.9/5 from 976+ clients, and has won three consecutive industry awards. No Win No Fee. 98% success rate on accepted cases.
Get My Free Assessment → 📞 0489 265 737 🛡️ ASIC Licensed ACL 532003 | ⭐ 4.9/5 from 976+ Reviews | 🏆 Award Winner 2022–2024
Australian Credit Solutions Pty Ltd holds Australian Credit Licence ACL 532003. Credit repair services are subject to individual assessment. Results may vary. This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal or financial advice.
Related reading: Best Credit Repair Company → | Default Removal Services →
Found Something Wrong on Your Credit File?
Our ASIC-licensed legal team has helped thousands of Australians remove invalid listings. Get a free assessment today.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Our Clients Say
928+ verified reviews from real clients
"After struggling with credit issues for years, I finally found a solution. The team's expertise and professionalism made the whole process smooth and stress-free."
"I had multiple enquiries hurting my score. The team explained exactly what could be done and delivered results faster than I expected. Worth every penny!"
"Professional, efficient, and they delivered exactly what they promised. My credit score improved significantly and I was able to refinance my mortgage at a much better rate."
"The best decision I made was calling these guys. They removed a default that had been on my file for years. Professional service from start to finish."
Elisa Rothschild
(BA/LLB)Principal Solicitor & Director
With over 12 years of experience in credit law, Elisa has helped thousands of Australians remove unfair credit listings and rebuild their financial futures. She leads Australian Credit Solutions' legal team with a focus on consumer advocacy and regulatory compliance.
Need help with your credit file? Get expert advice from our team.
Get Your Free AssessmentRelated Services
Professional solutions for your credit issues
Don't Wait — Credit Issues Get Worse Over Time
Get your free credit assessment today. Find out what's on your file and what can be fixed — before a lender does.
📚 Related Resources
Related Articles
Continue learning about credit repair
Are Credit Repair Companies Worth It in Australia? (Honest Answer)
Are credit repair companies worth it in Australia? An honest, balanced look a...
Read more →Average Credit Score in Australia (2026) — By Age & Bureau
What is the average credit score in Australia in 2026? Equifax national avera...
Read more →Bad Credit Score Australia: What It Means and How to Fix It
What counts as a bad credit score in Australia, what causes it, what it costs...
Read more →
